Rockhampton | Yeppoon | Brisbane 1800 329 448
Employment Law

Is Your Payroll Compliant?

Checking pay and classifications before someone else does — since intentional underpayment became a criminal offence on 1 January 2025.

The position changed on 1 January 2025

Intentional underpayment is now a criminal offence

Under section 327A of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth), an employer that engages in intentional conduct to fail to pay a required amount — wages, allowances, superannuation, leave entitlements — commits a criminal offence. Civil penalties for underpayment also increased substantially.

Honest mistakes are not the target, and a voluntary compliance code applies to small business. But "we never checked the award" is a materially riskier position than it was two years ago.

How underpayments actually happen

Almost none of the underpayments we see were deliberate. They arise from a small number of recurring errors that compound quietly over years.

  • Believing no modern award applies when one does
  • Classifying a role at the wrong award level
  • An annualised salary that does not cover the hours actually worked
  • A set-off clause that does not operate as intended
  • Missing allowances — travel, tools, meals, laundry
  • Overtime and penalties not applied to the correct hours
  • Casual loading applied to the wrong base rate
  • Superannuation calculated on the wrong earnings base

Classification is the single most common root cause. A role classified one level too low produces a small weekly shortfall that becomes a large sum across several employees and several years — plus superannuation and interest.

What we check

  • Which award or agreement applies to each role
  • Classification level for every employee
  • Base rates against the current award
  • Overtime, penalties and loadings
  • Allowances applicable to the work performed
  • Annualised salary and set-off arrangements
  • Superannuation calculation base
  • Leave accruals and payment on termination
  • Payslip and record-keeping compliance
Not certain your pay rates are right? Better to know now, on your terms.
Ask about an audit

The process

We agree the scope — which roles, which period — and the fee. The engagement is structured with legal professional privilege in mind from the outset, which matters if anything is found.

We determine which instrument covers each role and the correct classification, based on the work actually performed rather than the job title. This is where most issues originate.

Actual payments are compared against entitlements for the agreed period, including overtime, penalties, allowances and superannuation. Where volumes are large we work with a payroll specialist.

A written report setting out findings, quantum, and a rectification plan if one is needed — including what to fix prospectively so the same issue does not recur.

If we find an underpayment

Do not start back-paying before taking advice. That is not about concealment; it is that the calculation, documentation and communication of a rectification materially affect how it is treated.

A properly managed rectification — correctly calculated including superannuation and interest, clearly explained to affected employees, with the underlying cause fixed prospectively — is treated very differently from an ad hoc payment with no explanation. The former demonstrates good faith; the latter can create new problems, including employees who reasonably conclude something was concealed.

A note on privilege

An audit conducted by lawyers, properly structured, may attract legal professional privilege. An audit conducted internally or by a non-legal consultant generally does not.

That distinction matters if there is later a dispute or an investigation, because it affects whether the findings are discoverable. We structure engagements with that in mind from the outset, and it is a genuine reason to have this work done by a law firm rather than a payroll provider.

What it costs

  • Scoped and quoted before we start
  • Priced by number of roles and period reviewed
  • Payroll specialist costs disclosed separately
  • Written report included
  • Rectification work quoted separately
  • Far cheaper than a Fair Work Ombudsman investigation

Frequently asked questions

Intentional underpayment is. From 1 January 2025, section 327A of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) makes it an offence for an employer to engage in intentional conduct to fail to pay a required amount, including wages, allowances, superannuation and leave entitlements. Honest mistakes are not the target and a voluntary compliance code applies to small business.

Classification errors are the most common root cause — a role classified one level too low produces a small weekly shortfall that compounds across employees and years. Others include believing no award applies when one does, annualised salaries that do not cover actual hours, set-off clauses that do not operate as intended, and missed allowances.

Not before taking advice. How a rectification is calculated, documented and communicated materially affects how it is treated. A properly managed rectification, correctly calculated including superannuation and interest and with the cause fixed prospectively, is treated very differently from an ad hoc payment with no explanation.

Because an audit conducted by lawyers and properly structured may attract legal professional privilege, whereas one conducted internally or by a non-legal consultant generally does not. That affects whether the findings are discoverable if there is later a dispute or investigation.

It depends on your circumstances and risk profile, and it is part of the scoping conversation. Limitation periods apply to underpayment claims, but the practical scope is usually driven by when your current arrangements were put in place and when the relevant award last changed materially.

More information

Get payroll peace of mind without a full-scale audit. Our 4-part wage check package reviews high-risk pay areas to help you stay Fair-Work-compliant.

What You Get

Expert assessment without the premium cost

Industrial Instrument Coverage

Identify which awards or agreements apply to your workforce and spot any coverage risks, gaps, or role misalignments.

Review of Employment Contracts

Review contracts of three nominated employees to identify terms that breach awards or NES and flag non-compliant clauses.

Pay Rules Review

Review 2 weeks of rosters and payslips of the same employees as Part 2, checking ordinary hours, penalty rates, overtime, allowances, meal breaks, and award payment obligations.

Does not cover leave accruals or balances.

Records and Payslip Compliance

Check one employee’s time and wages records and payslips (from Parts 2 & 3) for compliance with Fair Work Act requirements.

Targeted Assessment

Focus on high-risk pay areas without the cost of a full audit

Expert Legal Review

Employment lawyers assess your compliance

Risk Mitigation

Spot the risks before they become penalties

Comprehensive Report

Detailed compliance report with clear findings

Tier 1

Normally 12h of expert work
Valued at $8,100 + GST

What’s Not Included

  • Full payroll audit across all employees
  • Leave accruals or entitlements audit
  • Back-pay calculations or remediation
  • Fair Work representation
  • Ongoing legal or HR advice
  • On-site payroll training
  • Superannuation compliance review

Need More Support? If we identify serious issues, we can propose a separate remediation project tailored to your needs.

Call us Book a consult