Rockhampton | Yeppoon | Brisbane 1800 329 448

How Many Times Can an Employee Sue Their Employer Over the Same Issue?

Stressed business owner reviewing piles of legal files and folders at his desk in a regional office

One employee. Multiple complaints. Different legal proceedings. But can an employer be forced to defend the same allegations over and over again?

Imagine this scenario.

An employee is placed on a performance improvement plan. They disagree with the performance concerns and lodge a bullying complaint against their manager. They then allege discrimination and lodge a complaint with a state anti-discrimination body.

Performance management continues, and the employee makes further allegations about how they are being treated. Eventually, their employment is terminated.

The employee then commences general protections proceedings under the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth), alleging that the performance management process and dismissal were unlawful.

For the employer, what started as a performance management issue has turned into multiple complaints, external proceedings, significant legal costs and considerable management time.

Sound familiar?

It raises an important question. Can an employee keep bringing different legal claims against their employer arising from essentially the same conduct?

It is a frustrating question we get asked a lot. The answer is not necessarily.

A decision of the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia, Farooq v ASX Operations Pty Limited (No 2) [2026] FedCFamC2G 2202, provides an important reminder that there are limits to an employee's ability to pursue overlapping legal proceedings.

An employee may be prevented from pursuing multiple claims over the same conduct. But that does not necessarily prevent them from bringing a separate claim arising from their dismissal.

Key points

  • Section 734 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) restricts general protections court applications about non-dismissal conduct already pursued under anti-discrimination legislation.
  • In Farooq v ASX Operations Pty Limited (No 2) [2026] FedCFamC2G 2202, allegations about performance improvement plans already raised with Anti-Discrimination NSW were struck out, but the dismissal claim proceeded.
  • Withdrawing the earlier complaint after starting the federal claim was too late to remove the restriction.
  • Earlier events can still be relevant background to a dismissal claim, and making complaints is never a lawful reason to dismiss.
  • Map every complaint, check for overlap, keep dismissal reasons separate from frustration about complaints, and consider preliminary arguments early.

Performance management is one of the more difficult responsibilities employers and managers have.

Employees do not always agree with the assessment of their performance. Some accept feedback and improve. Others dispute the concerns, question their manager's motives or allege that the process is unfair. And sometimes, those disagreements escalate into formal complaints and legal proceedings.

That does not mean those complaints are necessarily without merit. Employees have legitimate rights to raise concerns about discrimination, bullying and unlawful workplace conduct.

Equally, employers have the right to manage performance, set reasonable standards and make decisions about whether employees are meeting the requirements of their roles.

The difficulty arises when these two things collide.

Consider an employee who alleges that their performance improvement plan constitutes discrimination. They lodge a complaint with a state anti-discrimination body.

The same employee subsequently alleges that the performance improvement plan was adverse action because they exercised a workplace right. They then pursue the matter through the federal general protections jurisdiction.

Different legislation. Different legal arguments. Potentially different remedies. But the same underlying management decision.

Does changing the legal label allow an employee to pursue the same conduct through multiple jurisdictions? That was a central issue in Farooq.

The Farooq case: two proceedings, one performance management process

In Farooq v ASX Operations Pty Limited (No 2) [2026] FedCFamC2G 2202, Mr Asad Farooq had been employed by ASX Operations Pty Limited. During his employment, he was placed on performance improvement plans.

Mr Farooq challenged the employer's actions by lodging a complaint with Anti-Discrimination NSW, alleging discrimination arising from the performance management process.

His employment was subsequently terminated.

Following his dismissal, Mr Farooq commenced general protections proceedings in the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia. Importantly, his federal proceedings concerned two categories of conduct:

  • the performance improvement plans implemented during his employment
  • his subsequent dismissal.

The employer challenged the inclusion of the performance improvement plans as separate allegations of unlawful adverse action. Its argument was that Mr Farooq had already pursued those matters through the state anti-discrimination jurisdiction.

ASX Operations relied on section 734 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth), which restricts overlapping general protections and anti-discrimination proceedings concerning the same non-dismissal conduct. The employer sought to have the relevant parts of the federal claim struck out.

The Court agreed that the performance improvement plan allegations could not proceed as standalone general protections contraventions. However, the allegations concerning his dismissal were allowed to continue.

The employer succeeded in narrowing the litigation, but it did not eliminate the proceedings entirely.

This is particularly important for employers managing disputes involving repeated complaints.

What does the Fair Work Act say about multiple claims?

Part 6-1 of the Fair Work Act 2009 contains provisions designed to prevent certain multiple actions. The relevant provision in Farooq was section 734.

Broadly, section 734(1) prevents an employee from making a general protections court application concerning conduct that does not involve dismissal where:

  • the employee has already made a complaint or application concerning that conduct under anti-discrimination legislation or the Australian Human Rights Commission Act 1986; and
  • that earlier complaint or application has not been withdrawn or failed for want of jurisdiction.

The provision also restricts certain subsequent anti-discrimination complaints where a general protections court application concerning the same conduct has already been made.

The purpose is relatively straightforward. The legal system places limits on pursuing multiple overlapping statutory remedies for the same conduct. Otherwise, employers could potentially face repeated litigation arising from the same workplace decision simply because an employee chooses to characterise the conduct differently.

The focus is on the underlying conduct, not merely the legal label attached to it. In Farooq, describing the performance improvement plans as discrimination in one jurisdiction and adverse action in another did not overcome the statutory restriction.

However, section 734 is not a blanket prohibition against every type of workplace complaint. Internal grievances, workers' compensation claims, bullying applications and anti-discrimination complaints do not automatically trigger the same restrictions. The particular legislation, conduct and timing all matter.

Why timing matters: withdrawing a complaint may be too late

Another important aspect of Farooq concerned timing.

After commencing his federal claim, Mr Farooq sought to withdraw his earlier Anti-Discrimination NSW complaint. However, the relevant question was whether that complaint had been withdrawn, or had failed for want of jurisdiction, when the federal application was made.

It had not. The subsequent attempted withdrawal did not retrospectively remove the statutory restriction.

The Court also distinguished between a complaint being declined because it lacked substance and a complaint failing because the relevant body lacked jurisdiction. Those are different things. A complaint that has been rejected following an assessment of its substance has not necessarily failed for want of jurisdiction.

For employers, this creates a potential preliminary defence where an employee commences overlapping proceedings without properly resolving an earlier complaint. Rather than immediately defending every substantive allegation, it may be appropriate to investigate whether the later proceeding was validly commenced.

But the employee's dismissal claim was still allowed to proceed

This is where the decision becomes particularly interesting.

Although the Court prevented Mr Farooq from pursuing the performance improvement plans as separate general protections contraventions, it allowed his dismissal claim to continue.

Why? Because the dismissal was a distinct act from the earlier performance management decisions. The original Anti-Discrimination NSW complaint concerned the performance improvement plans. The subsequent federal proceedings also challenged the termination of employment.

Importantly, earlier performance management events could still be relevant as factual background when considering the reasons for dismissal. Preventing an employee from pursuing one legal claim does not necessarily remove the underlying events from consideration in another claim.

For example, inappropriate comments made during performance management may still be relevant when determining whether a later dismissal was motivated by an unlawful reason. Equally, a properly documented performance management process may help establish the employer's legitimate reasons for termination.

The lesson? Employers cannot assume that successfully striking out part of an employee's claim means the underlying conduct becomes irrelevant.

Want to speak with Jonathan about this?Employment Law advice for clients across Queensland.
Book a consultation

Is there a limit to employees making complaint after complaint?

Many employers will have encountered situations where an employee makes repeated complaints during performance management:

  • a complaint about their manager
  • then a complaint about the investigation
  • then a complaint about the performance management process
  • then an allegation of discrimination
  • then an allegation of adverse action.

Sometimes these complaints raise genuine issues requiring investigation. In other circumstances, complaints may become intertwined with efforts to challenge or delay legitimate management decisions.

The difficulty is determining how to respond without creating further legal exposure.

Under the general protections provisions of the Fair Work Act, employees may have protections when exercising workplace rights, including making certain complaints or inquiries concerning their employment.

However, making complaints does not provide an employee with immunity from legitimate performance management or dismissal. An employer may still take lawful management action. The critical issue is often why that action was taken.

  • Was the employee placed on a performance improvement plan because of genuine performance concerns, or because they complained about their manager?
  • Was the employee dismissed because they failed to meet reasonable performance standards, or because management had become frustrated with the complaints?

The reverse onus of proof under section 361 can also make the employer's evidence about its reasons for taking action particularly important. A poorly worded email suggesting that management has simply had enough of an employee's complaints could become damaging evidence.

What should employers do when faced with multiple employee complaints?

There are five practical lessons from Farooq.

1. Seek legal advice and map every complaint and application

Maintain a clear record of the allegations, relevant dates, jurisdictions and workplace events. Try to seek legal advice as soon as possible so there is a clear understanding of which legal issues may be intermingled.

A chronology may reveal that multiple applications concern essentially the same management decision.

2. Check whether the same conduct has already been pursued

Before defending a general protections court application, investigate whether the employee has previously lodged a relevant anti-discrimination complaint. Consider the status of that complaint when the later proceeding commenced and whether statutory restrictions apply.

3. Do not automatically stop legitimate performance management

An employee lodging a complaint does not necessarily mean performance management must cease, although we would always advise seeking legal advice when this occurs.

There may be reasons to pause, investigate allegations or appoint another decision-maker. However, employers can generally continue legitimate management action where it is lawful and appropriately handled.

4. Separate dismissal reasons from frustration about complaints

Decision-makers must be able to explain the legitimate reasons for termination. Avoid communications suggesting that an employee is being dismissed because they have made too many complaints.

Document performance concerns, procedural fairness and the actual reasons for the decision.

5. Consider preliminary legal arguments before defending every allegation

Farooq demonstrates that preliminary procedural arguments may narrow litigation. Where multiple proceedings overlap, employers should obtain advice about whether any claims are barred before committing significant resources to defending them.

The bigger lesson: repeated complaints are not unlimited legal rights

There is an important distinction between an employee's right to raise workplace complaints and their ability to pursue overlapping legal remedies.

Employees should be able to raise genuine concerns about discrimination, bullying and unlawful treatment without retaliation. Employers must take those concerns seriously.

But the legal system also recognises limits on multiple proceedings concerning the same conduct.

The earlier Federal Court decision in Deam v Starlight Children's Foundation Australia [2023] FCA 259 acknowledged that the strict operation of section 734 can sometimes produce harsh outcomes, particularly for employees navigating different jurisdictions without legal representation.

For employers, the challenge is not simply proving that an employee has made too many complaints. It is managing the employment relationship appropriately while understanding which legal claims can legitimately proceed.

Final thoughts: one workplace dispute should not automatically become multiple lawsuits

The Farooq decision provides employers with an important reminder. Just because an employee files another legal application does not necessarily mean the employer must defend every allegation as a fresh claim.

There may be statutory restrictions preventing employees from pursuing the same conduct through different legal avenues.

But employers should not become complacent. Earlier workplace events may remain relevant to a subsequent dismissal claim. And an employee making numerous complaints does not, by itself, provide a lawful reason to terminate their employment.

Frequently asked questions

Not always. Section 734 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) prevents a general protections court application about non-dismissal conduct where the employee has already made a complaint about that conduct under anti-discrimination legislation, unless it was withdrawn or failed for want of jurisdiction.

No. In Farooq v ASX Operations Pty Limited (No 2) [2026] FedCFamC2G 2202, the performance improvement plan allegations were struck out, but the dismissal claim was allowed to continue because the dismissal was a distinct act.

No. Making complaints can be exercising a workplace right, and the reverse onus under section 361 means the employer must prove its real reasons. Employers can still take lawful action for genuine performance concerns, but should document those reasons carefully.

Need assistance?

South Geldard Lawyers regularly assists employers, business leaders, CEOs, CFOs, HR teams and executives with:

  • Redundancy and restructure advice
  • Workplace bullying claims
  • Unfair dismissal
  • Sexual harassment matters
  • General protections
  • Psychosocial hazard management
  • Manager and leadership training
  • Performance management

If you would like to discuss a claim or potential claim against your business, contact our Employment Law Team on 1800 329 448 or send us an enquiry.

Filed under Employment, Articles


Related reading

Employment Law — our services   All insights

Call us Book a consult