Rockhampton | Yeppoon | Brisbane 1800 329 448

Psychosocial Risks: The New Weapon in Workplace Disputes?

Two managers in a tense meeting with an employee across a glass boardroom table in a city office

Psychosocial risks were supposed to be about protecting employees from psychological harm at work.

However, something interesting is happening.

Employers are now relying on psychosocial risks and hazards to justify dismissing managers. Businesses are using psychosocial safety concerns to support decisions to refuse employee leave requests. Employees are raising psychosocial hazards when challenging performance management, workplace investigations and other management decisions.

The same legal obligations designed to protect workers are increasingly being used on both sides of workplace disputes.

And for CEOs, directors, executives, boards and HR leaders, this raises an important question.

Are psychosocial risks becoming another legal weapon in workplace disputes?

Two Fair Work Commission decisions highlight how much the employment law landscape is changing.

Key points

  • Psychosocial hazard obligations under WHS law now feature on both sides of workplace disputes.
  • In Filamor v Port Stephens Veterans and Citizens Aged Care Ltd [2026] FWC 2484, a manager's dismissal for creating an unsafe psychosocial environment was upheld.
  • In Donnelly v Whitehaven Coal Mining Ltd [2026] FWC 3200, workload pressure on other staff supported reasonable business grounds to refuse a six-month parental leave extension, but a shorter extension was ordered.
  • Psychosocial safety is not a legal trump card. Each decision must still meet unfair dismissal, general protections, discrimination and Fair Work Act requirements.
  • Identify the actual risk, document the evidence and alternatives considered, and train managers in both WHS and employment law obligations.

Psychosocial risks are no longer just about bullying and harassment

For many employers, the initial response to psychosocial hazard legislation was reasonably straightforward:

  • Review the policies.
  • Train the managers.
  • Conduct a risk assessment.
  • Make sure employees know how to raise concerns.

Those obligations go much further.

Psychosocial hazards can arise from how work is structured, how decisions are made, the demands placed on employees and the interactions between people in the workplace.

Excessive workloads, poor organisational support, workplace conflict, unreasonable behaviour and inadequate supervision can all create risks of psychological harm.

Employers have obligations under applicable work health and safety legislation to eliminate or minimise those risks so far as is reasonably practicable.

However, those obligations do not exist separately from employment law. They can become relevant when an employer is:

  • considering terminating employment
  • responding to a leave request
  • investigating misconduct
  • managing an underperforming employee.

And sometimes the employer's obligation to protect one employee may need to be considered alongside the employment rights of another.

1. Psychosocial risks being used to justify dismissing managers

Imagine this situation.

A manager is demanding. They set high standards and expect employees to meet them.

Some employees complain about their management style. Others become distressed. Eventually employees begin resigning.

Does the employer have an obligation to intervene?

Potentially, yes. And depending on the circumstances, that intervention may include disciplinary action or dismissal.

In Filamor v Port Stephens Veterans and Citizens Aged Care Ltd [2026] FWC 2484, the Fair Work Commission considered the dismissal of a manager working for an aged care organisation.

The manager had been employed as a Lifestyle and Engagement Manager for less than a year. During that period, serious concerns emerged about her treatment of staff.

Evidence included employees being yelled at, spoken to rudely and becoming distressed at work. Two employees resigned, identifying the manager's conduct as a reason for leaving. Others indicated that they also wanted to resign.

The manager had also introduced an unauthorised disciplinary points system and had failed to comply with management directions.

Following an investigation, the employer dismissed her. One of the reasons relied upon was that she had created an unsafe psychosocial environment for the employees reporting to her.

The manager brought an unfair dismissal claim.

The Commission dismissed the application, finding that the dismissal was not harsh, unjust or unreasonable. Importantly, the Commission accepted that the employer had a valid reason to act in response to the manager's conduct.

The decision was not simply about a manager being unpopular or employees being unhappy. There was evidence of inappropriate behaviour, significant employee distress and other misconduct.

What does this mean for employers?

Employers have every right to expect managers to manage. That includes setting performance standards, providing feedback, giving directions and holding employees accountable.

Employees are not entitled to a workplace free from difficult conversations.

However, employers cannot simply dismiss complaints about a manager as employees being too sensitive. Where management behaviour creates a genuine risk to psychological health and safety, there may be a legal obligation to intervene.

The danger is at both extremes.

Failing to address genuinely harmful management behaviour may expose an employer to WHS and employment law risks. But treating every employee complaint about management as evidence of a psychosocial hazard could discourage legitimate performance management.

Not every tough manager is a bully. And not every employee who feels uncomfortable has been exposed to unlawful conduct.

The employer must examine the actual behaviour, the surrounding circumstances and the risk involved.

2. Psychosocial risks being used to refuse employee leave requests

The second decision takes psychosocial safety in a different direction.

What happens when granting one employee's request creates risks for everyone else?

In Donnelly v Whitehaven Coal Mining Ltd [2026] FWC 3200, the Fair Work Commission considered an employee's request to extend her unpaid parental leave.

The employee worked in a specialised data and analytics role. She requested an additional six months of parental leave. Her employer refused.

One of the important considerations was the impact that her continued absence would have on the employees covering her responsibilities.

The evidence before the Commission demonstrated that the team was already under considerable pressure:

  • Employees were working additional hours.
  • Managers were absorbing substantial workloads.
  • Some work was being delayed or missed.
  • There were concerns that continuing these arrangements would create unsustainable demands and risks to employee wellbeing.

The employer argued that allowing the further absence would prolong the pressure on the remaining employees, including the risk of burnout.

The Commission accepted that the employer had established reasonable business grounds to refuse the requested six-month extension. However, it did not reject any extension altogether. It ordered a shorter extension.

Why is this decision significant?

An employee's entitlement to request an extension of parental leave is an important workplace right. But the employer also has obligations to the employees who remain at work. And those obligations may become relevant when considering reasonable business grounds for refusing a request.

Psychosocial risks were not simply being raised as a complaint against the employer. They formed part of the employer's justification for its decision.

However, the decision does not give employers a general right to refuse parental leave extensions by claiming that other employees are stressed.

Under the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth), an employer must satisfy specific procedural and substantive requirements before refusing such a request. That includes genuinely attempting to reach agreement, considering the consequences of refusal for the employee and establishing reasonable business grounds.

Some questions to consider include:

  • What work is actually being performed?
  • How many additional hours are employees working?
  • What attempts have been made to recruit replacement staff or redistribute responsibilities?
  • What alternatives have been considered?

An employer that has simply failed to plan for an absence may have a much more difficult argument. And an employer that invokes psychosocial safety only after deciding to refuse a request may find its reasoning closely scrutinised.

Want to speak with Jonathan about this?Employment Law advice for clients across Queensland.
Book a consultation

3. Are psychosocial risks becoming an excuse for poor management decisions?

This is perhaps the more controversial issue.

As employers become more familiar with psychosocial obligations, there is a risk that the language of psychological safety becomes a convenient justification for decisions that might otherwise be difficult to defend.

  • An employer wants to refuse a flexible working request. It argues the arrangement will increase workload pressures on colleagues.
  • A business wants to discipline a manager. It characterises complaints about their management style as evidence of psychosocial harm.
  • An employee wants to resist performance management. They argue that the process is psychologically unsafe.

These situations may involve genuine risks. But they also raise a fundamental question.

Are psychosocial obligations being used to manage genuine workplace hazards, or are they being used to support a position already taken?

Psychosocial safety is not a legal trump card.

Simply identifying a potential psychological risk does not automatically justify dismissal, override an employee entitlement or establish that management action is unlawful. Each decision must still satisfy the relevant legal requirements.

For example, an employer cannot assume that invoking its WHS obligations automatically displaces its responsibilities under discrimination, general protections or unfair dismissal legislation.

Nor can an employee assume that describing management action as psychologically unsafe makes that action unlawful.

The legal position will depend on the facts, the nature of the risk, the action taken and the particular statutory obligations involved.

This is why the evidence supporting a decision is often more important than the terminology used to describe it.

What should employers be doing differently?

The response should not be to treat every workplace disagreement as a psychosocial hazard. Nor should employers become reluctant to make difficult management decisions.

Instead, psychosocial risk management needs to become part of how those decisions are made.

  • First, understand the actual risk. Do not assume that a complaint establishes a hazard or that a difficult workplace decision necessarily creates an unacceptable risk. Examine the circumstances objectively.
  • Second, distinguish between employee dissatisfaction and genuine psychosocial hazards. Employees may disagree with decisions, dislike management directions or become distressed during legitimate workplace processes. Those responses deserve consideration, but they do not automatically establish a breach of WHS legislation.
  • Third, consider the effect of decisions on the broader workforce. The Whitehaven Coal decision demonstrates why workload pressures and the effects on other employees may be relevant when considering certain employment requests.
  • Fourth, document the reasoning behind important decisions. If psychosocial safety is genuinely influencing a decision, employers should be able to identify the risk, explain the evidence supporting it and demonstrate what alternatives or controls were considered.
  • Finally, train managers to understand both their employment law and WHS obligations. Managers need to know when to intervene, when to seek advice and how to continue reasonable management action while appropriately addressing psychosocial safety concerns.

The obligation is to identify genuine risks, take appropriate steps to manage them and make legally defensible decisions.

For CEOs, boards and HR leaders, the challenge is ensuring that psychosocial safety becomes part of sound management and governance. Not simply another weapon used when workplace relationships break down.

Frequently asked questions

Potentially. In Filamor v Port Stephens Veterans and Citizens Aged Care Ltd [2026] FWC 2484, the Fair Work Commission found a manager's dismissal was not harsh, unjust or unreasonable where there was evidence of staff being yelled at, employee distress, resignations and other misconduct. Complaints alone are not enough; the employer must examine the actual behaviour and risk.

In Donnelly v Whitehaven Coal Mining Ltd [2026] FWC 3200, workload pressure and burnout risk for the remaining team supported refusing a six-month parental leave extension, although the Commission ordered a shorter extension. Employers must still meet the Fair Work Act's procedural and substantive requirements.

No. Identifying a psychological risk does not automatically justify dismissal, override an employee entitlement or make management action unlawful. The outcome depends on the facts, the nature of the risk, the action taken and the statutory obligations involved.

Need assistance?

South Geldard Lawyers regularly assists employers, business leaders, CEOs, CFOs, HR teams and executives with:

  • Redundancy and restructure advice
  • Workplace bullying claims
  • Unfair dismissal
  • Sexual harassment matters
  • General protections
  • Psychosocial hazard management
  • Manager and leadership training
  • Performance management

If you would like to discuss psychosocial risk and hazard management, contact our Employment Law Team on 1800 329 448 or send us an enquiry.

Filed under Employment, Articles


Related reading

Employment Law — our services   All insights

Call us Book a consult